Answer / vikram

The above answer is partly incorrect. First, the delivery
quantity is 40 not 60. Delivery related invoice will only
apply if you create a delivery. In standard 3rd party
scenario normally you don't create delivery as the vendor
delivers the goods to customer. So copy control will be F
which means "Invoice receipt quantity less invoiced
quantity"

However, you can do the following:

Create sales order for 100 pcs. This will automatically
create a PR and subsequently a PO is created for 100 pcs.
The vendor delivers 40. At this point, do a GR (MIGO) for
40 pcs and then MIRO for 40 pcs. Now go back into the sales
order and change the sales order quantity to 40pcs (and
save)and invoice the customer for the 40 pcs. This will
effectively close the sales order.

I have done this and it has worked. Let me know if it works
for you too.

Answer / vikram

I agree with subramanyam and would also go and say that it
would be a better idea to update the sales order with the
quantity actually delivered, else it might give conflicting
information when the sale order and invoice are seeing in
parallel.

Answer / subrahmanyam

In this case, create the customer invoice for 40 qty only
after vendor invoice verification completes and then set
the status as "Completed or Fully referenced" to the Sales
Order.

Answer / pitabash, infosys, pune

Hi All !

if the vender supplies qty is 40 , then he will invoice
only for 40 qty .

According to the Billing relevance in Item category "F"
which means (F Order-related billing doc. - status
according to invoice qty)
here clearly mention that the status according to the
invoice qty of the vender. So after the invoice
verification we should bill the qty only 40 not 100.

So for the rest 60 qty . To close the sales order we need
to change the qty in sales order. & create another order
for 60qty to another vender r same vender later on.


Please let me know if I m worng.

Pitabash
Infosys, pune
pitabash.sap@gmail.com

Answer / vikram

Rajiv,

What you are saying is called "trading process" where the
vendor delivers the goods to you and then you deliver it to
the customer. That is correct. In such cases, billing
relevance will be delivery related billing.

In the above case, it is stated that the vendor delivers
the quantity or 40 pcs. So in this case, the billing
relevance is "F" which is correct. Also this question is
very commonly asked in the interivews and they are looking
for "third party" related answers not individual purchase
orders.

So....I guess we both are correct!

Answer / subha

Hi Rajiv

The secenario that you are talking to relates to creating
puirchase order where you do the complete setting where
thepp or mm dept sends the purschase order through MB56 and
the supplier sends you goods and you delivery . but this
question realates to THIRD PARTY SALES. here i betthe
billing cannot beon delivery based it is always order based

Answer / vikram

Hi Subha,

What you are saying is correct. But the billing quantity is
not going to be order quantity. It is "Invoice receipt
quantity less invoiced quantity", reason being if the order
quantity is 10 and the vendor has delivered 5, then the
bill or invoice cannot be order quantity as you will end up
charging the customer for 10 pcs. So it has to be invoice
receipt qty less invoiced quantity which is 5.

Answer / rajiv trivedi

Question is not understood well so
reply is wrong. Q is How to close sales Order. There are 2
things to be checked/done.

1) Reduce the quantity backt to 60 in the sales order.
2) Check how Billing is created through copy control. See
item category TAS TCode VOV7 BILLING RELEVANCE

If it is "F" order related than it will be billed for
100Pcs whilst delivery is only 60Pcs. It should be changed
to "K" Delivery Related-Invoices for Partial Quantity

Or "H" Delivery Related-No zero quantity.

So question is tricky to understand that how further
billing is effected for that proper closing is required.

I am 100% sure that this is correct answer. If any question
how it is wrong please explain me.

rajiv2856@yahoo.ca

Answer / harikrishna

Dear pitabash u have correctly answered but one thing when
it"supllioed we can customize for 1 time delivery and what
ever it"s delivered will lead to close the order .

and the invo0ice will be raised as per delivery invoice and
billing releveance is K".

Answer / subha

to the above what subramaiyan had said i would like to add
is you need to give drop shipiment to the thrid party for
other 60 or how will the thrid party know how much to realse
and delivery

131. Are you familiar with billing output determination? Suppose if I’m creating an invoice, and I want to print out the output of the invoice, how would I do that? Are you familiar with any output that prints out SAP for that invoice so further delivery for example, in delivery you have backing slips delivery....

0 Answers  

After returning the materials In MMBE it shows the return material quantity is 0 Actually I have 3 storage location 1st one is son1 for finished materials,2nd one son2 for return materials and 3rd one son3 for scrap So 1st I made a sales order with quantity 20 with storage location son1 and made the delivery and invoiced. Now when i am checking the material through mmbe then i found 20 materials less. Now I am going to return material and made a sales order(va01-document type RE) and clicked with reference with sales order and next clicked on copy button Next I mentioned the order reason as poor quality and went to goto item level and specified another storage location as son2. Saved the sales order and next made the delivery-vl01n (with delivery type LR) and did PGR and saved the delivery. But when i am checking the material quantity in mmbe with storage location son2,at there I can’t find any return material.the return quantity is 0. So what is the problem in my configuration??

4 Answers  

Hi Friends, Can any one of you give me /share the difficult / most challenging High priority / Emergency /medium tickets as this question is asked more frequently in all SAP SD interviews. Please provide 2-3 most difficult/ typical rare issues /tickets which can be explained easily in interview. Also give full error , your analysis & your final resolution to that issue.Plz do not give websites names-- give tickets directly. Based on this question the interviewer is selecting/ rejecting the candidates. So,this question is more important as it is playing a key role in selection of candidate. Please help me in this regard. Many thanks in advance.

1 Answers  

What are the influence factors for account determination for invoices?

0 Answers  

Hi,In IBM Interview,the Scenario For an XYZ customer any order he places should be deliveried with in time and one short all the QTY (one time only PGI for Sales order). say for example Customer has ordered 100 qty on 15/july/2011, stock aviable is only 30 qty, customer requied delivery date 25/july/ 2011. is this possiblein SAP SD if yes How and where is the Triggering point.

4 Answers   IBM,

Fullform or Longform of ECC 6.00

10 Answers  

Hi friends. I am srinivas. I want to know the text determinatin. What is the text determination. What is that use. Where can we use text determination in real time. Pls explain me in detial with example.

0 Answers  

Hi Experts,In a third party Sales Order process suppose the Sales order has quantity 50 but the vendor delivers only 20 item quantity then how does the business knows that the vendor has delivered only 20 pieces qty only? I have been asked this question in a recent interview. Please answer to this question asap....

6 Answers   Bosch, Keane India Ltd,

what type of tools do u use after creation of a sales order for quality checks???

1 Answers   Satyam,

What is ticketing ? and what problems u have solve in ?

5 Answers   TCS,

Can we sell the same material from two different divisions.

9 Answers   Bosch,

Are there any user exits or any other way to include new fields in the sales order va01?

0 Answers