Difference b/w Co-product & by-Product
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / rajesh
Co-products/By-products are products which are produced
alongwith the finished product.They are products which are
not intentionally produced but which we get when we are
producing the finished product (which is being produced
intentionally).
In some industries the products which are produced alongwith
the finished product do not have much value.These products
are By-products and the company would get a very small value
for these products as compared to the actual finished
products in the market.In such cases tracking/financial
details for such materials don't hold importance for the
company.
In some other industries the products which are produced
alongwith the finished product have considerable value
(sometimes 15 - 20% of the finished product).These products
are Co-products and get a good value for the company when
they are sold in the market.
Co-products are considered more important as compared to
By-products.We have to maintain a lot more data for
Co-products as compared to By-products.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 32 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / k.jayachandrasekhar
CO-PRODUCT
------------
A co-product is a product that is produced in along with
other products. The system creates a separate order item in
the production order for each co-product. This means that
it is possible to display actual costs at co-product level.
Main product and co-product(s) are settled to different
receivers. Goods movements can be posted simultaneously for
all products manufactured in the order
BY-PRODUCT
----------
A by-product is a product that is produced along with other
products. The system doesnot create a separate order item
for each by-product.
The material valuation of a by-product is always based on
the price specified by price control in the material master.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 6 Yes | 0 No |
In simple terms, the co-product and By-products are
secondary products produced along with Finishied Good. The
difference is
--> Co-Product has market/ sale value and can produce alone.
--> By-Product has Small/ No market/ sale value and it may
incurr some cost to dispose it. This cannot be produced
alone.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 9 Yes | 5 No |
Answer / girish pawar
The ANSWER 1 by Rajesh is correct ,
I want to add some more example with this
Example of co product is During machining process of the
casing of pump , the brass shavings are produced . Theses
brass shvings are again sold back to refiner company who
sold you the brass ignots initially for forging or casting
process.
So Brass shavings can be a co product , as it is valued and
costed for the company .
And the example for the BY-product is the COOLING OIL
,which is used to cool the cutting blades of tool , which is
collected again and used once or twice again and set for
the proper disposal , but not sold outside , that is you
need not to settle cost , and no credits for sale .
So it can be by-product , it is valued but not costed,
Both have non-zero inventory valuation .
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 2 No |
Answer / prabhu
Co-Product:Is the product produced along with the parent
material.For Co-Product seperate production order will be
created.
By_product:Is the product produced along with the parent
material.For Co-Product no seperate production order will be
created.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / shib shaw
CO-PRODUCT
------------
Both co-productand by-product is a product that is
produced in along with Finish products. The basic diff
between Co nad By -product the value of by product will be
go to Main Product . in case of co product has some
separate cost to display.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 2 No |
Do you have any idea about Capacity Planning?
How can we shut off the "automatic costing indicator" and the "automatic scheduling indicator" which go on when the production order is released?
What are the tools used in SAP PP support project?
What do you mean by pooled capacity?
Can’t one material be assigned to more than one operation in a routine?
Explain what is PRT – how many types of PRT is used?
What are commmon tickets in SAP PP in support project,examples?
Hi All, In Repititive manufacturing during backflush we enter the production date and the batch. The classification for production date and Shelf life expiration date has been maintained in the material master. We have a characteristic "date of last goods reciept"which updates the characteristic value in the batch classification automatically from the production date entered in MFBF Tcode. Even though we have maintained the min shelf life and total shelf life the system does not calculate the remaining shelf life for the batch and does not update the value for shelf life in batch classification. Please suggest the procedure for updating values in batch classification for shelf life automatically from MFBF Regards, LN
What are the strategy groups you have used?
What MRP does with Capacity overload
What is the recruitment cycle?
Integration between PP and SD module.
SAP Basis (1262)
SAP ABAP (3939)
SAPScript (236)
SAP SD (Sales & Distribution) (2717)
SAP MM (Material Management) (912)
SAP QM (Quality Management) (99)
SAP PP (Production Planning) (523)
SAP PM (Plant Maintenance) (252)
SAP PS (Project Systems) (138)
SAP FI-CO (Financial Accounting & Controlling) (2766)
SAP HR (Human Resource Management) (1180)
SAP CRM (Customer Relationship Management) (432)
SAP SRM (Supplier Relationship Management) (132)
SAP APO (Advanced Planner Optimizer) (92)
SAP BW (Business Warehouse) (896)
SAP Business Workflow (72)
SAP Security (597)
SAP Interfaces (74)
SAP Netweaver (282)
SAP ALE IDocs (163)
SAP Business One (110)
SAP BO BOBJ (Business Objects) (388)
SAP CPS (Central Process Scheduling) (14)
SAP GTS (Global Trade Services) (21)
SAP Hybris (132)
SAP HANA (700)
SAP PI (Process Integration) (113)
SAP PO (Process Orchestration) (25)
SAP BI (Business Intelligence) (174)
SAP BPC (Business Planning and Consolidation) (38)
SAP BODS (Business Objects Data Services) (49)
SAP BODI (Business Objects Data Integrator) (26)
SAP Ariba (9)
SAP Fiori (45)
SAP EWM (Extended Warehouse Management) (58)
Sap R/3 (150)
SAP FSCM Financial Supply Chain Management (101)
SAP WM (Warehouse Management) (31)
SAP GRC (Governance Risk and Compliance) (64)
SAP MDM (Master Data Management) (0)
SAP MRS (Multi Resource Scheduling) (0)
SAP ESS MSS (Employee Manager Self Service) (13)
SAP CS (Customer Service) (0)
SAP TRM (Treasury and Risk Management) (0)
SAP Web Dynpro ABAP (198)
SAP IBP (Integrated Business Planning) (0)
SAP OO-ABAP (Object Oriented ABAP) (70)
SAP S/4 HANA Finance (Simple Finance) (143)
SAP FS-CD (Collections and Disbursements) (0)
SAP PLM (Product Lifecycle Management) (0)
SAP SuccessFactors (33)
SAP Vistex (0)
SAP ISR (IS Retail) (28)
SAP IdM (Identity Management) (0)
SAP IM (Investment Management) (0)
SAP UI5 (59)
SAP SCM (Supply Chain Management) (51)
SAP XI (Exchange Infrastructure) (49)
SAP Cloud Platform (34)
SAP Testing (89)
SAP SolMan (Solution Manager) (63)
SAP MaxDB (116)
SAP GUI (15)
SAP AllOther (329)