which transmission is cheaper ac or dc?
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / eng_entropy
I agree with Manya and adding that:-
1-HVDC transimission line have lower losses than Ac lines
for the same power capacity.
2-It is very easy to control the active power in the link
in HVDC systems.
3-HVDC system is the only way to make an exchange of power
between two different networks.
HVDC . . . High Voltage DC system
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 16 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / j@ru ( sati)
i am agree wiyh above all and adding that the ac
transmission is cheaper at a distance called breakdown
distance which is about 800-1000 km .above this distance of
transmission line dc is cheaper ..but it should be noted
that the initial cost of installation for dc is more than
ac.as rectifier station installation is costly.
thank you
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 9 Yes | 0 No |
Both transmission have there own advantages &
disadvantages..
However for Lond distance say 1000 Km distribution the DC
transmission is cheaper because of Line losses but in short
distance AC is cheaper because the Cost of AC DC coverter
Substation is very high.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 7 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / rishav gaurav
Ty
pical
advantages
of
hig
h
voltage
DC
transmission over
hig
h
voltage
AC
transmission
are
listed
below
:
1.
No
stabilit
y
problems
due
to
transmission
line length
since
no
reactive
power
needs to
be
transmitted.
2.
No
limitation
of
cable
lengths for
underground
cable
or
submarine
cable
transmission
due
to
the
fact that
no
charging
power
compensation
needs
be
done.
3.
AC
power
systems
can
be
interconnected
employing
a
DC
tie
wit
hout
reference to
system
frequencies,
shor
t-circuit
power,
etc.
4.
High-speed
control
of
DC
power
transmission is
possible
because
the
control
ang
le,
a,
has
a
relatively
shor
t
time
constant.
5.
Fault
isolation
between
receiving
end
and
sending
end
can
be
dynamically
achieved
due
to
fast
efficient
control
of
the
hig
h
voltage
DC link.
6.
Employing
simple-control
logic
can
change
the
energ
y
flow
direction
ver
y
fast.
This
can
help
in
meeting
peak
demands
at
either
the
sending or the receiving station.
7. High reliability of thyristor converter and inverter
stations makes this mode of transmission a
viable solution for transmission lengths typically over 500 kms.
8. The right-of-way needed for high voltage DC transmission
is much lower than that for AC
transmission of the same power capacity.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 3 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / manya
dc transmission is cheaper above break down distance means
it is cheaper for long distance.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 7 Yes | 6 No |
ac transmission is cheaper though the losses in this are
high compared to dc
because dc cannot be stepped up directly and so the the
inverters and rectifiers comes into picture which has to
deal the high powers (in the order of mw).asn so the cost
is high
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 2 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / sym
in my opinion AC transmission is cheaper compared to DC.
losses due to DC transmission are more compared to AC
transmission.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 23 No |
A 12.5 hp slip ring motor taking high initial current and its MPCB is getting open.what may be the reason?
Given a ckt,the max power dissipated in the load ZL ?
what is an alternator & generator
WHAT IS LINE TRAP,HOW IS IT FUNCTION?
What should be the BDV value of a new transformer oil
what is ups?how its works?and what is there in static switch how it works?
How much allowable difference current between on three phases Dear sir, We have a 1870 KW HT motor, 11 Kv supply,FLA-120A,2870 rpm,2-pole squirrel cage induction Motor.And stator is connected in star connection with Liquid resistance stater to limit the starting current.It has coupled with Centrifugal air compressor.My question is it is loading 73% of FLA taking R-phase 86.7 A, Y-phase-85.4A,B-phase- 78.3A.why the B phase current is that much of difference.Is it allowable, or any one tell me how much allowable current.If any method to calculate.
is the electrical energy photo copy possible or not???????????? give me some idea about that i m very great full tu u.
what effect on electrical equipment if PF is gone over 0.996 in leading when provider say that its keep in minimum 0.996lagging
WHY IS wet surface used for grounding???
how much watts the computer will takes
How to know the back up time for a 5KVA UPS which is connected to 15 nos. of computers? Is there any formula for this? pls. tell me.
Civil Engineering (5086)
Mechanical Engineering (4456)
Electrical Engineering (16639)
Electronics Communications (3918)
Chemical Engineering (1095)
Aeronautical Engineering (239)
Bio Engineering (96)
Metallurgy (361)
Industrial Engineering (259)
Instrumentation (3014)
Automobile Engineering (332)
Mechatronics Engineering (97)
Marine Engineering (124)
Power Plant Engineering (172)
Textile Engineering (575)
Production Engineering (25)
Satellite Systems Engineering (106)
Engineering AllOther (1379)