Answer / www.islamqa.com

First let's take a quick brief history about controllers:

1 - For analog control loops we have a stand alone PID controller.

2 - Then we get a networked PID controllers through a hub and HMI for configuring and monitoring.
The PID itself contain a network port.
SIEMENS introduced PID 353 & PROCIDIA software for it.

3 - Then we get DDC - DIRECT DIGITAL CONTROL, single CPU, I/O'S for analog instruments only & networked PC is an option.
SIEMENS introduced APOGEE, FISHER introduced ROC.
has disadv. of system halting/failure.

4 - The next phase is DCS - Distributed Control System, and this is first introduced by HONEYWELL & YOKOGAWA.
Ability for handling large scale of I/O'S, discrete and analog, complex control loops, PID algorithms calculations and executions.

5 - PLC is basically designed and produced for discrete on/off control, limited I/O'S.
but modern PLC with great progress in h/w technology introduced itself as a less expensive option for PID, with it's complicated calculations and algorithms.

6 - by the time with great achievements in H/W tech. and networking capabilities the single PLC can handle discrete and analog instruments with wide range.

7 - Now the man can make his own DCS with multible networked PLC'S, but it will need a great engineering and effortsto get near from DCS features and functionality.

Regards,

Ahmed Sabry
Control and Instrumentation Engineer
GPC - General Petroleum Company
ahmedsabry.online@gmail.com
CELL.: 00 2 0121367310

Answer / tauqeer hassan

plc is a programmable logic controller which can handle the
binary input and output of the logic statement which are
stored in its memory.its a digitally operating system whic
are logic stored in its memory by programming system.

DCS:-Distributed control system its control all types of
process variable at a time through this we can control the
whole plant,we can see the status of plant,and handling yhe
unit.

Answer / eid elatawy

PLC is a programmable logic controller which take the inputs from the system and execute it through the program written by Ladder or STL (statement list)language and provide the output to the system.the famous CO Siemens,Allen Bradly.

DCS is distributed control system the same idea for PLC for take the input and execute it through the program to provide the output.the famous CO Yokogawa,Honeywell


We can enumerate the difference as following:-
PLC
1- no of points less.and almost of these points digital points.
2- no of analog points very less.
3- trends and history not allowed.
4- used for machines and separate units with HMI and in this case called SCADA system.
5- cost is less and easy to make extension.
6-scanning time less.

DCS
1- you can use more than 10000 points
2- no of analog points more.
3- trends and history allowed and saved in server for along time.
4- used for a big plants like oil&gas-chemicals and petrochemicals..
5-cost very high and you have to min cost of the system + no of points separate. so the extension not easy like PLC
6- Scanning time more than PLC.
7- We can monitor the all inputs and control all outputs

Regards

Eid Elatawy
I&C Engineer
TCI sanmar chemicals CO
Port said
Egypt
contact no- 002 01000470262
mail- eng.eid72@gmail.com

Answer / ghazanfar ali

In PLC the Scan time is less.but the scan time of DCS is
high.Because it Control the whole plant. So in safty llop
we used PLC

Define the difference between a stable versus an unstable controlled system and some of the tools you might use to be able to detect when this is happening and assumptions used for control system application design that could contribute to instability

0 Answers  

---

if I did short to both AO connections, channel will burn or what? m sure in AI it will damage to channel. But what will happens in AO?

1 Answers  

---

wat are the interview questions asked in air india for post service engineer

1 Answers   AirIndia, Shree Renuka Sugars,

---

Hi friends, from Aug 4th onwards iam getting spikes for analog inputs in our DCS for a period of 800ms. I throughly checked every thing, finally i found that the DI, DO's from MCC panels shields are terminated in the Signal Earth where Analog Input signals shields are terminated. Is there any problem with this type of termination?. i checked the induction voltage from MCC and getting around 25VAC, please suggest me in this concern. Our plant is 8months old only. DCS is Siemens Make Simatic PCS7, and the transmitters are Yokogawa make.

1 Answers  

---

if we put any thermocouple on a table in a room without any connection,what temperature should it show.

3 Answers  

---

---

1 How to calculate dp transmitter steam and water? 2 impulse line for liquid steam and gas

1 Answers   Sitara Chemical Industries,

---

Name different parts of a pressure gauge.

0 Answers  

---

Can combine control system for Emergency control system (ESD)and Fire & Gas System ( F & G) is possble to built and offer to client? Can such system is as per Norms in India?

0 Answers  

---

what is difference between PLC and DCS?

10 Answers  

---

how flame detectors sense the flame.

3 Answers  

---

WHAT IS ANNUBAR?

7 Answers  

---

How to force the bit in GE Mark V?

1 Answers  

---