What is the difference between Server.Transfer and
Response.Redirect? Why would I choose one over the other?
Answers were Sorted based on User's Feedback
Answer / vishal jani
Nitya u r wrong , in server.transfer is reliable then
response.redirect ,server.transfer will not create any
cookie and it will take u on the requested page directly and
taking less time then response.redirect.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 7 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / vaibhav nagar
Response.Redirect sends message to the browser saying it to
move to some
different page, while server.transfer does not send any
message to the browser
but rather redirects the user directly from the server
itself. So in server.transfer
there is no round trip while response.redirect has a round
trip and hence puts
a load on server.
Using Server.Transfer you can not redirect to a different
from the server itself.
Example if your server is www.yahoo.com you can not use
server.transfer to move
to www.microsoft.com but yes you can move to
www.yahoo.com/travels, i.e.
within websites. This cross server redirect is possible
only using
Response.redirect.
With server.transfer you can preserve your information. It
has a parameter
called as “preserveForm”. So the existing query string etc.
will be able in the
calling page.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 7 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / ramgopal reddy
Server.Transfer is used to post a form to another page.
Response.Redirect is used to redirect the user to another
page or site.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 7 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / rohan more
Incase of Server.Transfer ,it doesnot cause rod trip to
client and also it does not store url history and directly
redirect to the requested page without changing URL(Please
note).It transfer from Server itself.
where as in case of Response.redirect it cause round trip
to client browser and then transfer from page which cause
request to redirected page.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / sudhir kunnure
Server.Tranfer direct shows requested page without any
server side roundtrip.
But response.redirect it round trip to server then shows
requested website or page.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 4 Yes | 1 No |
Answer / kumar saurabh
In earlier versions of IIS, if we wanted to send a user to a new Web page, the only option we had was Response.Redirect. While this method does accomplish our goal, it has several important drawbacks. The biggest problem is that this method causes each page to be treated as a separate transaction. Besides making it difficult to maintain your transactional integrity, Response.Redirect introduces some additional headaches. First, it prevents good encapsulation of code. Second, you lose access to all of the properties in the Request object. Sure, there are workarounds, but they're difficult. Finally, Response.Redirect necessitates a round trip to the client, which, on high-volume sites, causes scalability problems.
As you might suspect, Server.Transfer fixes all of these problems. It does this by performing the transfer on the server without requiring a roundtrip to the client.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / sulochana singh
Server.Transfer() : client is shown as it is on the requesting page only, but the all the content is of the requested page. Data can be persist accros the pages using Context.Item collection, which is one of the best way to transfer data from one page to another keeping the page state alive.
Response.Dedirect() :client know the physical location (page name and query string as well). Context.Items loses the persisitance when nevigate to destination page. In earlier versions of IIS, if we wanted to send a user to a new Web page, the only option we had was Response.Redirect. While this method does accomplish our goal, it has several important drawbacks. The biggest problem is that this method causes each page to be treated as a separate transaction. Besides making it difficult to maintain your transactional integrity, Response.Redirect introduces some additional headaches. First, it prevents good encapsulation of code. Second, you lose access to all of the properties in the Request object. Sure, there are workarounds, but they're difficult. Finally, Response.Redirect necessitates a round trip to the client, which, on high-volume sites, causes scalability problems. As you might suspect, Server.Transfer fixes all of these problems. It does this by performing the transfer on the server without requiring a roundtrip to the client.
Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 0 No |
Answer / nitya
Both r used to redirect webform
Server.Transfer fetches page from Server .. while
it will take time..
response.redirect directly open described page..
Is This Answer Correct ? | 0 Yes | 8 No |
What is bson in web api?
In C#.net application is run on linux michine
What are the Application_Start and Session_Start subroutines used for?
What is viewstate?
How can we make sure that Web API returns JSON data only?
What is difference between cookies and cache?
What are the features of asp net?
how we can solve machine key error in asp.net?
what is diffrance between response.write & response.output.write
Explain the different types of assemblies?
Is it possible to develop a single web application using ASP.NET webforms and ASP.MVC?
Explain Assemblies?,Difference between Panel and GroupBox?,Differences between ASP and ASP.NET?