in india why 50 hz and 220 volt taken as standard rating for
equipments whereas in US 100hz and 110v is consided as
standard rating.is this method save power.
Answer Posted / shafeeq
A lot of points are factored when a utility decides to
choose 50 or 60 hertz, sometimes it may even been a
political rather than a technical one. We have seen various
types of wars on measurements types of units used or have
been an interested but an innocent invitee in format wars
in electronics like 8 track v/s cassette, v2000 (an
excellent system) V/s the betamax (also with some notable
features) and the vhs. Now we are also extended into the
video disc formats. However if we were to look closely many
of us will agree that 60hz is a good choice. All inductors
and motors could be smaller, and the benefits will
encompass a wide array of electrical and electronic goods
to which the changes will almost be transparent. But it
should be noted that most critical and large capital
intensive plants and machinery, including certain medical
equipment, will not take too kindly to such a change,
which, besides straying from the critical specs, or worse
still may give up altogether, unless expensive time
consuming replacement or an equally complicated and
efficient cycle converter is installed before the system is
connected to the mains.
As a historical note, 60Hz was originally chosen in the US
to help market AC power systems to customers. The ploy was
that a clock could run using a synchronous AC motor and at
60Hz, the gear mechanism would be greatly simplified. Then
the job of keeping accurate time fell to the electricity
company by maintaining a constant frequency. Prior to this,
many different frequencies had been tried.
As regards 50 Hz in India it is descendant of the British
Imperial system. Technically speaking operating 50 Hz
versus 60 Hz would not make much difference but, to achieve
it, either the prime movers - for example steam turbines,
gas turbines and diesel engines - would need to be able to
tolerate a 20% increase in speed or the alternators they
drive - which produce the electricity - would need to be
completely rebuilt with extra poles and windings so that
they could continue to run at the same rotational speed.
The costs of doing such re-engineering would be enormous
and could not be justified as "economically worthwhile"
from the point of view of actual necessity, quite apart
from the severe problems which would be caused to assuring
operational continuity of service whilst such changes were
made.
Further, for any load equipment - machines, appliances,
etc. - that have reactive components
(capacitors/inductors), the effects of a frequency change
from 50 Hz to 60 Hz on such impedances would not be trivial
and would significantly alter their in-circuit behaviour.
This means changes would have to be made to the sizes all
such reactive components to achieve the same effects at the
higher frequency. Doing that would be yet another enormous
cost of conversion from 50 Hz to 60 Hz which could not be
justified as economically worthwhile.
| Is This Answer Correct ? | 5 Yes | 3 No |
Post New Answer View All Answers
What is line resistance of cable & how it can be measured ?
What Is Connection APFC Panel In Compony.
a governer in an Ic engine controls the
how to select the isolation tranformer for siemens 802dsl cnotroller
how to calculate percentage impedence at 75 deg C at normal tap
In a carnot engine with an efficiency of 40%, the heat rejected to the sink at 27 C is 60 kJ, then the heat supplied in kJ to the engine by the sources is
how the synchronizing is obtained at bus couplers in grid substation? (because there we cannot change the frequency in one of transmission lines like in generator synchronization)
can someone explain that how the speed of the protection system affects the fault level calculation?
Why frame of the motor is specified?. If we mention KW and voltage level,automatically frame is decided or separately frame is compulsory to mention?.
if voltage bt phase & nutral is 38v in a panel board . whats the root cause.
From what on-site components does the HT panel monitoring the bus-bars in a 11kV system take inputs?
i applied for c licence with my one year apperents trainee and i have attaced with A grade contractor company experiance that is for 14 monts experiance this document is sufeicant for c licence? pls tell why they rejected
How is the connection of the tap changer on the HV side been made?
Difference between transition and diffusion capacitance
What are the limitations of Kirchoff's laws?