i am swathi, b.tech 4th year.
In smps(switched mode power supply)we are using
diodes,mosfets,igbts for controling of current.
And my question is why we did not use thyristors(scr)? it
is also act as a switch,then what is the drawback of scr as
compared to above transisters> if we use the scr,then what
is happening ? plz give reply as soon as possible bcoz i
am doing project on smps. plz frnds i want ans for
that. if anybody know the ans plz send to my e-mail
id /swathi.tadakapally@gmail.com/

Answer Posted / nithi

SCR cannot be used due to the following reason.

1.we have to design commutation circuit for SCR.(this will
increase the complexity of the circuit)

2.cost of SCR is higher than MOSFET,TRANSISTOR & IGBT.

3.SCR is current controlled device .This will increase the
load on the triggering circuit.

4.The voltage drop & power loss in SCR is somewhat higher
than mosfet,igbt & transistor.

5.moreover,the switching frequency of the SCR is very low
(around 1khz).

so,I think it is better to use MOSFET,IGBT & TRANSISTOR as
a switching device in SMPS.OK............

Is This Answer Correct ?    19 Yes 3 No



Post New Answer       View All Answers


Please Help Members By Posting Answers For Below Questions

How do I calculate a WTI CT ofa 1250kVA 6600/400V transformer

1303


1. A 380 / 220 V r.m.s. 3-phase 4-wire circuit carries loads of 8 + j8.1 ohm; 4 + j4.1 ohm; and 2 +j2.1 ohmin the three phases respectively. The length of the circuit is 100 m, and the resistivity of the phase conductors is 0.0005 Ω/m. The neutral conductor is of the same size as the phase conductors. a) Select a reference angle 0for the first phase. Then write down the three phase voltages in both polar format and complex number format. b) Make appropriate assumptions, and take temperature effects on resistance is insignificant. Calculate the currents in the three phases. (Note: Determine conductor resistance, and apply Kirchhoff’s Voltage Law) Based on the result, suggest a main switch rating for the circuit. c) Show your preferred direction of neutral current in a diagram, and then determine its value. (Note: Apply superposition principle, and Kirchhoff’s Current Law) Use its magnitude to show that in this circuit, the unbalanced load may increase the voltage drop in some of the phases. (Note: Also observe the common volt drip in neutral) State your assumptions, if there are any. d) Suddenly the neutral wire of the circuit is broken. Estimate the new currents in the first phase, i.e. Phase L1. State your assumptions, if there are any.

1478


What is the function of under voltage release ?

984


regarding safety what would u consider the most important rules to observe when inspecting electrical equipment?

1574


what is the difference between pvc & fiber glass cables

1044






why various test are performed on electrical panels & power cables before commissioning on site & what are these test???

1522


can any one suggest me the tilt angle of my solar pannel ?? or tell me how can i know the fix tilt angle of my solar pannel?? my cordinates are 31.503629,72.993164.

1375


What are the necessary solutions needed to be carried out on a malfunctioned earthing mechanism of a VACUUM CIRCUIT BREAKER.(TAMCO)

1532


Stator of 3-phase IM has 3 slots per pole per phase. If supply frequency is 50 Hz, calculate the speed of rotating stator flux A 1000 rpm B 500 rpm C 1500 rpm D 1440 rpm

1674


I PURCHASED A DEISEL GENARATOR SET OF AVR TYPE& RATING 125KVA BUT SOME TIMES THE OUTPUT VOLTAGE IS FLUCTUATING WHAT ARE THE PROBABLE REASONS GIVE ME

1404


What is referred to the electron in the outer orbit?

703


What is the Current equation in series RLC circuits.

616


If the earth is a good conductor of electricity, why don't people get shocked every time they walking on earth?

1302


how to calculate the breaking capacity of different breakers.

1688


In 90 kva alternator that produce the output voltage is 115(p-n),200(p-p) at 1500 rpms means what ampere it produced ?

1598