What are the difference between C-Curve and D-Curve for
MCB's.

Answer Posted / h.shastri

almost all answer is somewhat correct

the main thing is to selection of proper MCB which matches
with your equipments and instruments

for that i'd like to give you an case study...

let's Assume one Heating Control Action

suppose i am using a 1ph. heater of 1200 Watt (5.2 Amps)
now i am controlling heating action using an SSR or
relay/contactor

now if i will select SSR (relay/contactor)'s rating =6 amps
and i also impliment MCB of 6 Amps.b-curve

then in case of heater failer or implimenting different
rating's heater,

assume that circuit is taking some higher current say, 10
Amps in such my SSR(relay/contactor)will damage due to high
load current which is higher then their rating of 6 Amps

but MCB will not trip instently ( it trips after 5-10 min.
because load current is not more then 12 Amps)

in this case MCB will not protect your instruments.

now if i'll decrease MCB's rating it will starts tripping
on and on.....

if i'll select MCB more then 6 Amps again in this case MCB
will not trip

so that, if i m using b curve 6 Amps MCB then i must select
SSR(relay/contactor)'s rating more then 12 Amps say 15Amps.
then and then problem will be solve.

also if i will use MCB of C or D curve then Again i have to
choose instruments which has atleast 3-5 times higher
rating of MCB.

Is This Answer Correct ?    66 Yes 12 No



Post New Answer       View All Answers


Please Help Members By Posting Answers For Below Questions

Can i use the B-curve MCB instead of C-curve MCB

1601


What is acsr cable and where we use it?

721


at meter room 50 hrc switch installed,but there are not get earthing proper,so what happen?and 11kv transformer out put going in to hrc main 400a three nog each? so earthing is require for all switch? (some customer made earthing at there home.)

1470


how do i work out the Amps of a incommer if i am running 1 37 KW motor and a 0,75 KW motor and some solinoids

1428


why ht cable end termination don't have a gland?

2309






If any HVDC line is going with positive & negative(the negative usually have return path of current with earthing electrode). Now the question is if this HVDC earthed electrode which is using as return path and earthed any nearby 400kv or 220kv AC substation equipments. which will be the impact of this on AC substation & its equipment, how severe may be this and what should be the minimum distance require between HVDC earthed electrode and AC substation equipments? It's really an high engineering level question...Dare to answer and increase your knowledge.

1475


whatis the commertial spec. of distribution boards ?

1542


What is float cum boost charging system?

1589


How to measure current and voltage in an ELV circuit

3620


What is the lockout relay

1068


What is the need of generator relay panel

1526


in cvt,there are two windings,1a,1n and 2a,2n.in my one project i use only one winding i.e.1a,1n. the other winding is not in use, so i connect it in open delta and want to close it by ibsertibg thermal resistor. the output of cvt is 132kv/115/sqrt3. plesae tell me exact value of resistor, so i may close it to avoid the resonance phenomenin. send me answer on this email adress please. aetcon-po@aetcon.com

2163


what is the differencce inn series and cascade connection??

4244


What is the difference between acs 550 & acs 850

5378


You are of electrical field and you are going for software? Why

1856